Star Tribune: Burger Friday

The burger: The classic California cheeseburger lives a very good life at Nightingale, ramped up by the cooking smarts of chef/co-owner Carrie McCabe-Johnston. Let’s break it down, shall we? The patty – which weights in just over the 1/4-lb. – could not be more tantalizing. It’s a half-and-half mix of chuck roast and fatty brisket, and comes with a primo pedigree: family-owned Peterson Limousin Beef near Osceola, Wis. The meat is ground in-house, and it’s so good that the only seasoning that McCabe-Johnston adds is salt, in two stages: permeating the meat while it’s being ground, and sprinkled on the surface of the patty just before it hits the stove. They’re fried on a flattop, with the patties caramelizing in their own juices. “That was a decision I made early on,” said McCabe-Johnston. “I wanted something greasy and delicious. Diner-style, you know? That’s what I love.” Same here. Talk about a big, bold, beefy bite, and the brisket’s creamy fat makes for an outrageously juicy burger experience.

View the Whole Article at star

Nightingale is now open for Brunch!

Every Sunday from 10-3, we offer our take on Brunch Classics.  Eggs Benedict with dill cured gravlax, asparagus and preserved lemon hollandaise; Smoked Pork Shoulder with masa cakes, guajillo sauce, avocado salsa and fried eggs; Yeasted Waffles with seasonal fruit and maple syrup and more! Of course, we have delicious Brunch Cocktails as well. Nightingale Bloody Mary, complete with house-pickled green beans and a pony of High Life; Grapelli-Cava, St. Germaine & Raspberry puree; Gin & Juice-Gin, Campari, grapefruit juice & soda water; and more…

Nightingale News!

We have a lot of new things going on at Nightingale.

The Minnesota spring weather is finally here and we now have outdoor seating!

Every Sunday night from 10pm-2am, we have a house DJ.  End your weekend with music and our Happy Hour offerings (11-1).

Taco Tuesday!  Every Tuesday, we offer a different taco for $4.  Recent offerings have included Grilled Pink Snapper Escabeche with Pineapple marinated Cabbage, Chorizo Sausage with Goat cheese and Smoked Jalapenos & Pickled Shiitakes with Napa Cabbage-Sesame Slaw and Rice.  Check out our Facebook page every Tuesday to see what the nightly Taco will be.

Spring Beer Dinner with Boom Island Brewing

Please join us Monday April 22nd  for a Spring focused four-course dinner featuring beers from Boom Island Brewing.


Scallop Crudo

burnt orange, green almonds, watercress
Silvius Pale Ale

Chilled English Pea Soup

smoked salmon, beer bread croutons
Brimstone Trippel

Beer Braised Leg of Lamb

asparagus tortellini, morels, ramps
HooDoo Dubbel

Maple-Brown Butter Cake

orange blossom poached rhubarb
Witness Witbier


Reservations are required.

Please call 612.354.7060.

CityPages: Nightingale Lures Twin Cities Night Owls

I had been working in restaurants since I was a teenager, so it was important to us to give people in the industry somewhere to go when their shift is over that serves the whole menu, not just a limited late-night thing.” Limited it’s not, but the spread isn’t overwhelming either.

Divided into snacks, bruschettas, and small plates, McCabe-Johnston’s menu is eclectic with a bit of a French twist. I’d recommend ordering two plates per person and making your own little painter’s palette of food with a spoonful or slice from each dish.

Then get a bit of freshness and crunch with the lively market salad, which is subject to change but for now features figs, fennel, dry jack cheese, and a vinegar-heavy dressing made with walnuts. Finally, get into the real meat of the meal with the braised pork shoulder (Brasa’s influence really comes out in this dish) with roasted red peppers atop little squares of stiffened grits.

View the full article at


Food Service News: Nightingale Takes Flight

Carrie McCabe Johnston and her husband Jasha Johnston dreamt of a little place of their own for over a decade. But as these things go, they had to wait for the right place at the right time. Imbibing at the CC Club one night, the couple said they kept glancing over at the gutted convenience store at 26th Street West and Lyndale Avenue. “That’s it,” they agreed.

You’ll find some subtle NOLA influences throughout, like the shrimp and grits that will appear on the eventual brunch menu, but there’s also a blue booth that Carrie discovered at a beloved New Orleans eatery. She handed that one image to Kate, and the designer got busy. “She also told me that she liked mid-century modern mixed with vintage, and she loves New Orleans, so I just started Googling words and images,” Kate says. “I Googled thousands of them. Finally I came up with this one image.”

That’s where those comfy blue booths come in, as does buttery white upholstery on the chairs and barstools that pop against the otherwise dark room. Wood floors give the effect that the place has been around forever, which is where the classic part of the equation comes in. “We had to be very careful about that—so it will stand the test of time,” Kate says

View the full article on Food Service News


Star Tribune Restaurant Review: Nightingale Sings Sweet Melody

That mentality kicks off with the kinds of nibbles that naturally pair up with the bar’s libations: addictive olives, well-appointed cheese and charcuterie plates, a few fresh oysters and creamy, dill-flecked deviled eggs garnished with a luxurious caviar finish. They’re all fine; terrific, even. But then the real fun starts.

The spectacular meatballs could be the centerpiece of a first-rate red sauce joint, that’s how good they are, an almost pillowy blend of chuck roast and pork shoulder, milk and Parmesan, served in a lively, marjoram-packed tomato sauce. Because McCabe-Johnston rarely repeats herself, it’s difficult to grow restless, although the reasonable prices will encourage repeat visits.

View the full article on the Star Tribune
 Beer meets Nosh at Nightingale

This Uptown small plates eatery is a labor of love for the couple, who fuel their enterprise with culinary careers that include stints at the renowned haute cuisine / sophisticated famille fare duo of Alma and Brasa (Carrie) and 14 years of bartending at Mortimer’s (Jasha). And when it came to putting together the restaurant’s beer menu, they found another love story at the heart of a beer brand that they’ve turned into the Nightingale hallmark: Boom Island Brewing Company, the Belgian-style beer made and sold by Qiuxia and Kevin Welch. “They came out here and we did a tasting with them, and it was husband and wife, doing their thing, and husband and wife, doing our thing,” recalls McCabe-Johnston. “It was great seeing people living their dream as a couple. It mirrored what we’re doing here.”

View the Whole Article at